Cathy TrenaryIntegrative TherapyLet’s Connect
Menu
Anxiety and Depression

When your mind will not stop running through every outcome

You send the email and then reread it four times. You lie awake drafting a conversation that may never happen. People who overthink are often told to stop worrying, which has never once helped. I would start by asking what all that thinking is trying to do for you.

What Overthinking Looks Like Day to Day

It tends to take two forms. One looks backward: replaying what you said, searching for the mistake. The other looks ahead: running through what could go wrong so you will be ready for it. Either way, the mind is busy and nothing gets settled. Many people describe being tired and wired at once, with a body that stays tense even on a quiet day.

The Job It Is Trying to Do

Anxiety usually develops for a reason. In Internal Family Systems, an approach I draw on often in individual work, we would say a part of you has taken on the job of keeping you safe by anticipating every problem. It has been working overtime for a long time, and it does not believe it can stop.

Why Arguing With It Backfires

Telling yourself to calm down sets up a fight inside: one part worries, another criticizes the worrying, and now you are anxious about being anxious. Distraction works for an hour. What I see help more is turning toward the worry with some curiosity, the way you would with a friend who keeps calling with the same concern. What is it afraid will happen if it stops checking?

Your Body Is Part of the Loop

Overthinking feels like it happens from the neck up, yet the body is involved the whole time: shallow breathing, tight shoulders, a clenched jaw. A nervous system on alert sends the mind looking for a reason. Sometimes the most direct way to quiet a thought is to work with the body first, with a longer exhale, feet on the floor, or a walk around the block.

A Few Things to Try

Write the worry down in one sentence and ask whether there is an action to take today. If there is, take it. If there is none, say so to yourself in plain words. Set aside fifteen minutes in the afternoon to think it through on purpose, and when it shows up at midnight, remind it of the appointment.

When It Is Wearing You Down

Consider talking with someone if the thinking is costing you sleep, making decisions feel impossible, or pulling you away from the people you are with. If you also notice physical symptoms that worry you, check in with your doctor. Therapy works alongside medical care and does not replace it.

How I Work With Overthinking

In individual therapy, we get to know the part of you that overthinks and what it has been guarding against. I combine Internal Family Systems with mindfulness and somatic awareness, along with practical tools for the moments when your mind takes off. As that part feels understood rather than pushed away, your nervous system can begin to settle.

If your mind has been running like this for a while, you can bring exactly that to a consultation. It is free, 20 minutes, and there is no need to have it figured out first.

A Free Consultation

Keep Reading

All Guides on Anxiety and Depression

This guide is general education. It is not therapy, a diagnosis, or medical advice, and reading it does not create a therapist-client relationship.

Couple sitting together on a beach
Let’s Connect

Start with a conversation.

A free 20-minute consultation is a place to talk about what you need and see how we might work together.

Contact Cathy
Cathy Trenary

Before We Meet

Quick answers, not a live chat. Please do not share personal or clinical information here.