Cathy TrenaryIntegrative TherapyLet’s Connect
Menu
Communication and Conflict

You raise one concern and get a list of reasons back

You mention that the trash did not go out, and within a minute you are hearing about their week, your tone, and the thing you forgot in March. You wanted a small acknowledgment. You got a closing argument. If most of your concerns end this way, you may have stopped raising them at all, which carries its own cost.

What Defensiveness Sounds Like

It has a few familiar shapes. There is the explanation: “I only did that because you were late.” There is the counter-complaint: “What about when you did the same thing?” And there is the collapse: “Fine, I am a terrible partner.” All three move the conversation away from what you came to say.

What the Armor Is For

I think of defensiveness as a protective part doing its job. Your partner hears your concern and, underneath, hears a verdict: you are failing, you are not enough. The explaining is an attempt to get out from under that feeling quickly. It is still unpleasant to be on the other end, and it helps to know what the reaction is answering.

Complaint or Criticism

The Gottman Method draws a line here that I find useful. A complaint is about one event and how it affected you: “The trash is still here and I am frustrated, because I asked this morning.” Criticism is about who your partner is: “You never follow through.” Your partner can answer a complaint. Faced with criticism, most people defend themselves.

Words like always and never, and questions that begin with “Why can’t you,” tend to turn a fair complaint into a charge.

Before You Speak

Ask yourself what you want to walk away with. An apology? A change next week? To be understood? Knowing that helps you make one request. For the opening sentence itself, I have written separately about how to bring up a hard topic.

When the Explaining Starts

Resist debating the facts. Whether you were twelve minutes late or twenty will not settle anything. Try naming what you are after: “I believe you had reasons. I still want you to know how that evening was for me.” Then stop talking and give your partner a moment to take it in.

Your Own Reflex

Most of us are defensive about something. Notice what happens in your chest when your partner brings a concern to you. If you can say, “You are right about that part,” even when you disagree with the rest, you show what you are asking for.

Asking for a Different Response

On a calm day, say what would help. “When I bring something up, I am not building a case. It would mean a lot if the first thing you said was what you heard.”

Practicing This in Session

When this happens in a couples session, I stop the exchange at the moment the armor goes up and ask each of you what just happened inside. The partner who defends gets to say what they heard. The partner who raised the concern gets to say it again, more simply. We repeat that until it starts to feel possible at home.

I am glad to hear about it if you want to reach out. And if you have gone quiet about things that matter in order to avoid the reaction, start by saying that much out loud to someone.

A Free Consultation

Keep Reading

All Guides on Communication and Conflict

This guide is general education. It is not therapy, a diagnosis, or medical advice, and reading it does not create a therapist-client relationship.

Couple sitting together on a beach
Let’s Connect

Start with a conversation.

A free 20-minute consultation is a place to talk about what you need and see how we might work together.

Contact Cathy
Cathy Trenary

Before We Meet

Quick answers, not a live chat. Please do not share personal or clinical information here.