Cathy TrenaryIntegrative TherapyLet’s Connect
Menu
Communication and Conflict

The argument ended. The issue is still sitting there.

Your arguments tend to end the same way. Someone gets tired, or a child walks in, or one of you apologizes for your tone. Things go back to normal. But nothing was decided, and you both know the subject will be back within the month, exactly where you left it.

Two Kinds of Problems

The Gottman Method separates disagreements into two groups, and I find the distinction a relief for couples. Some problems are solvable. They are about a situation: who drives the Tuesday carpool, how to pay for the new roof. Others are ongoing. They come from lasting differences between two people, such as a saver married to a spender, or someone who loves a full house married to someone who needs quiet.

How to Tell Which One You Have

Ask whether a practical arrangement would settle it. If yes, it is probably solvable, and you may simply never have finished the conversation. If you have reached agreements several times and the issue returns in a new form, you are likely dealing with a difference in temperament or values. The topic keeps coming back because the two of you are still who you are.

Finishing a Solvable Problem

Take one topic at a time, at a time you have both agreed to. Each of you proposes something specific. Choose one arrangement to try for two weeks, and put a date on the calendar to review it. Treating the first answer as an experiment takes the pressure off getting it right.

A Different Goal for Ongoing Ones

For a lasting difference, the aim shifts from settling it to talking about it well. That may sound like giving up. In practice it means you stop trying to convert each other. Couples who manage these differences still disagree about money or tidiness after decades. They can discuss it without either person feeling attacked for who they are.

Ask What It Means

Stuck positions usually have a story under them. Ask your partner, “What does this mean to you? Where does it come from?” The saver may tell you about a parent who lost a job. The one who wants the house full may describe a lonely childhood. You are not obligated to give in once you hear it. You will probably argue differently.

Find Where Each of You Can Bend

Each of you names the part you cannot give up and the parts where you have room. “I need some savings we don’t touch. I can be flexible about how we spend the rest.” Arrangements built this way are temporary and get revisited, which is fine. You are managing a difference, and that is ongoing work.

When a Topic Has Frozen

Pay attention if a subject has become untouchable, or if every mention leaves one of you feeling rejected as a person. That is harder to thaw alone. It is also a good reason to bring in a third person.

What an Assessment Shows

Couples therapy with me often begins with a Gottman assessment. It gives us a picture of your strengths and of where conflict gets stuck, which helps us sort the two kinds. That picture tells us where to put our effort first.

If you can name the argument that never finishes, bring it to a consultation. We will have 20 minutes, at no cost, to talk about which kind it might be.

A Free Consultation

Keep Reading

All Guides on Communication and Conflict

This guide is general education. It is not therapy, a diagnosis, or medical advice, and reading it does not create a therapist-client relationship.

Couple sitting together on a beach
Let’s Connect

Start with a conversation.

A free 20-minute consultation is a place to talk about what you need and see how we might work together.

Contact Cathy
Cathy Trenary

Before We Meet

Quick answers, not a live chat. Please do not share personal or clinical information here.